Sole trader or limited company: which suits a UK online seller?
Sole trader or limited company for a UK online seller: tax, admin, liability, how marketplaces see each, when to switch, and the key HMRC thresholds.
By the SellSail team · Updated · 7 min read
Key takeaways
- Most new online sellers start as sole traders: it is quick, cheap and simple to run.
- A limited company separates your personal and business finances and can be more tax efficient as profits grow.
- VAT registration depends on turnover, not on whether you are a sole trader or a company.
- Get advice from an accountant before switching; the right answer depends on your profits and plans.
Most UK online sellers start as a sole trader because it is quick and cheap to set up, and move to a limited company when profits grow or they want to separate personal and business risk. Neither choice stops you selling on OnBuy, Amazon or eBay. The right one depends on your profit, your appetite for admin and your plans.
This guide is general information, not tax advice. Speak to an accountant before you decide.
What is the difference?
| Sole trader | Limited company | |
|---|---|---|
| Set-up | Register with HMRC for Self Assessment | Incorporate at Companies House, then register for Corporation Tax |
| Legal identity | You and the business are the same | The company is a separate legal person |
| Liability | You are personally liable for business debts | Liability is generally limited to the company |
| Tax on profit | Income Tax and National Insurance | Corporation Tax, then tax on what you take out |
| Admin | Annual Self Assessment return | Annual accounts, confirmation statement, Corporation Tax return, payroll if you pay salaries |
| Privacy | Your name is the business | Directors and the registered office are on the public register |
Which is more tax efficient?
At low profits, a sole trader usually pays less once you count accountancy costs. As profits rise, a limited company can be more efficient, because company profits pay Corporation Tax (currently 19% to 25% depending on profit) and you choose how and when to take money out. The crossover point depends on your income from other sources, so an accountant should run your numbers.
Does it affect VAT?
No. VAT registration depends on your VAT-taxable turnover, not your business structure. You must register when turnover passes the threshold (£90,000 in any rolling 12 months at the time of writing), and you can register voluntarily below it. Read our VAT guide for online sellers for how VAT affects marketplace pricing.
How do marketplaces and suppliers see each?
- Marketplaces accept both. You will go through identity and business verification either way.
- Wholesalers sometimes prefer a company number or VAT number for trade accounts, though many accept sole traders.
- Payment providers and banks may ask for more checks on companies (directors and beneficial owners).
When should you switch to a limited company?
Common triggers:
- Profits have grown to the point where your accountant says it saves tax.
- You want to protect personal assets from business risks.
- You want to bring in a partner or investor.
- Suppliers or partners you want to work with prefer a company.
Switching means new marketplace verification, a business bank account in the company's name and updating suppliers, so plan it rather than rushing it.
Costs that apply either way
Whatever your structure, know your true cost per sale: product, delivery, marketplace commission, VAT, payment fees and software. Our guide to the hidden costs of selling online lists them, and the OnBuy fee calculator works out your profit per sale.